Pie Bar

valerie lesly a month ago

NOT A REAL KEY LIME PIE! If you are wanting a traditional Key Lime pie with graham cracker crust and the normal filling, this is not where you buy it. My husband ordered a key lime pie for our son’s 30th birthday this weekend on the spur of the moment when that was what my son said he wanted instead of cake. What a surprise and disappointment it was when we cut into it and discovered that it was lime flavored cool whip filling, not a key lime pie! Disappointing to say the least! Just now I noticed the owner responded to another surprised customer saying the filling is made with cream cheese and condensed milk, fooled me! We would have been better off buying a Marie Callander pie from the grocery store for less than $10.

Eric J 4 months ago

Stopped by on the way to a movie for a sweet treat. Order taking was quick and everything tasted great. Prices were also pretty fair. There was plenty of seating and also board games available. Great spot for a treat.

Jake Zeke 4 months ago

Not only are the Pies AMAZING, but the staff are incredible and just decent humans. A man who was struggling and clearly had not eaten in a while went up with a couple of bucks. The nicest lady at the counter pushed the money away and gave him a cookie and a drink on the house. A little humanity goes a long way! Will be back!!!

Louisa Simeri 8 months ago

Good pie, mostly creamed. Advertised coffee, however it was a 6 minute wait for my decaf coffee I ordered and even longer for regular. They only have one pot I guess? We came in kind of late in the day so they might not have had any left? I don’t know, satisfactory experience with employees but the pie was good!! Unfortunate that the coffee we ordered to come with the pie took a very long time… and also there was a concerning amount of grounds in the coffee.

Lau Marti 11 months ago

The moment we walked in, I loved how peaceful, clean, and beautifully decorated this place is. It feels cozy and well put together. The staff was super nice — especially the girl with blue or green eyes, she was so kind, genuine, and respectful. It was our first time here with my husband and two kids, and we all loved it. The mousses are so good! I tried the brownie one, my kids had the Oreo (they thought it was ice cream at first!), and I also tried the pumpkin one — all were delicious. I also had a slice of the Black Forest cheesecake pie, which was amazing and made me want to come back to try the lemon pie next time. Everything was great! The only thing I’d personally prefer is for the mousses and pies to be served a bit colder instead of room temperature — but that’s just my personal taste. It doesn’t take away from how good everything was. Totally recommend this place!